Guide to the Rare Book Appraisal and Evaluation Process

December 16, 2023

The Purpose of Rare Book Appraisal

People often seek rare book appraisals to obtain an official fair market replacement value for various reasons. This can include insurance purposes, inheritance matters, or determining the value for charitable donations.

When it comes to the appraisal of rare or collectible books, understanding the nuances of the evaluation process is key.

At Britannic Auctions, we strive to provide a thorough and accurate assessment of books that are submitted to us for auction, though these same basic concepts are used throughout the auction and rare book industry.

In this guide, we’ll delve deeper into the basics of the usual appraisal process, shedding light on the factors that contribute to determining the value of your rare books.

Initiating a Rare Book Appraisal

Traditionally, a rare book appraisal could only be had in-person.

This is still a great option for those who have a rare book store or library with a rare book collection nearby. Some local book shops welcome walk-ins for assessments of collectible books, while others will require that you make an appointment. Contact your local rare book store of choice and ask about their process.

You can also find a comprehensive list of all accredited rare book dealers with the Antiquarian Booksellers’ Association of America. The ABAA is known for promoting ethical standards and providing a platform for reputable dealers specializing in rare and collectible books.

What to Expect With An In-Person Appraisal

When engaging in an in-person appraisal with a rare book dealer, the process typically involves presenting the book physically to the expert.

The dealer will carefully examine various aspects, including the book’s title, author, date of publication, and, most importantly, its condition. The condition assessment may involve a close inspection of the binding, pages, and any potential signs of wear and tear.

In some cases, the dealer may request additional information or documentation about the book’s history, ownership, or any significant events related to its provenance. This thorough examination allows the rare book dealer to provide a more accurate and informed appraisal based on both the physical characteristics of the book and its historical context.

How to Request an Online Appraisal

The internet now provides book collectors with a wide array of virtual options, allowing them to choose from numerous rare book dealers, appraisers, and auction houses.

To kickstart an online appraisal, you’ll be asked to provide essential information. This includes key details such as the book’s title, author, publication date, and, crucially, the overall condition of the book.

Submitting Photos for Appraisal

Providing comprehensive and clear images of your books is incredibly important for an online appraisal. These images will aid in a better understanding of the book and also streamline the assessment process.

Sharing clear, high-quality photos allows for a detailed examination and more accurate evaluation of your book. Whether capturing the specifics on a title page, showcasing the binding, unique illustrations, or revealing signs of wear and tear, these images play a pivotal role in assessing the book.

Insurance Appraisals for Rare Books and Collections

An insurance appraisal for rare books is a professional assessment conducted to determine the value of a rare book specifically for insurance purposes.

A formal insurance appraisal helps establish the appropriate amount of insurance coverage needed to protect the book in case of loss, theft, or damage.

For insurance purposes, most homeowner policies have a collectibles limit, requiring a special rider for coverage. An appraisal is often needed, and the most cost-effective method is to create a detailed list of valuable books, including author, title, publisher, date, edition, and brief descriptions.

Note that insurance costs for book collections vary among companies. It’s advisable to check with your insurance company for a quote, as requirements and premiums can differ significantly. Some insurers may have stringent requirements, such as frequent updates, while others may offer more reasonable terms.

How Price is Determined

Specific prices and price ranges are not determined by simply using marketplace websites like AbeBooks, Biblio or Amazon. These sites tend to give a false reflection of the real worth of collectible books. (Learn why many online book prices are misleading.)

While these platforms provide a snapshot of “asking prices,” they often fail to reflect the true market value.

The old adage is true: “Something is only worth what someone is willing to pay for it.”

The professional approach extends beyond these public websites. Professionals delve into auction databases, examining actual historic sales prices, specialist catalogs and networking with other professionals.

Many of these resources are usually out of the grasp of an everyday collector. While there are some resources available to research prices, it’s important to note that these are often subscription based and can be quite expensive.

Key Points in Rare Book Appraisal

In rare book appraisal, experts focus on critical elements: historical importance, condition, scarcity, and demand. These key points ensure a thorough evaluation, determining the book’s true market value accurately.

The Age of the Book

Just because a book is old doesn’t mean it is automatically valuable. This rule of thumb can be surprising to people trying to sell old books. Consider these two examples:

  1. “Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone” (First Edition, 1997): At a 2018 auction in London, this copy fetched an impressive $162,500.
  2. “The History of France” (Full Leather, 1688): An antique copy of this large set of books, bound in full leather has, in some instances, sold at auction for as little as $20.

Clearly, age alone doesn’t always determine a book’s worth.

The Collectibility of the Book

Certain authors or subject matters always have a following and a base of collectors; if a book is in high demand, it tends to be worth more money.

The same goes for first editions; a first or early printing often commands a greater value.

The Rarity of the Book

A rare book doesn’t always mean it’s a valuable book.

For example, we’ve dealt with many hundreds of old books which would be classified as being rare, but which in actuality didn’t achieve any significant value at auction.

This is due to the fact that although the books were indeed rare and hard to find, they were not particularly collectible or highly desirable.

The Condition of the Book

As with all antiques, condition plays a major role in desirability.

For example, if an antique book is in poor condition it might only be worth 10% of an identical copy in very good condition.

There are some exceptions to this rule and here’s when rarity comes into play. If you have an exceptionally rare book, then even if it is in poor condition it could still hold a lot of value.

Conclusion: Find the Auction Value of Your Rare Book

To sum it up, the rare book appraisal process delves into the historical significance, desirability, and condition of your books, whether they’re rare treasures or more common editions. By drawing comparisons between valuable rarities and less sought after copies, a rare book dealer or auction house can offer a detailed assessment, giving you a clear understanding of your book’s worth.

If you’d like to get a free appraisal for a rare or collectible book, we welcome you to submit details and photos of your book for potential auction consignment.

EXPLORE & LEARN

Learning Guides

In-depth guides on the world of collecting and valuing books, postcards, photography and more.

Have an antique in your attic and wonder what it's worth?

Get Alerts for the Dickensiana Auction

 

Join our mailing list for email alerts on the 2023 Charles Dickens auction.

Thanks for your interest! You'll be hearing from us.

Get auction updates for whatever you collect!

 

Join our mailing list to receive periodic email alerts on our upcoming online auctions.

Let us know your area of collecting or interest and we'll send you updates on that particular subject.

INTERESTS

Thanks for your interest! You'll be hearing from us.

Get auction updates for similar items

 

Join our mailing list to receive periodic email alerts on our upcoming online auctions.

Let us know your area of collecting or interest and we'll send you updates on that particular subject.

Thanks for your interest! You'll be hearing from us.

Get auction updates for similar items

 

Join our mailing list to receive periodic email alerts on our upcoming online auctions which feature vintage Hollywood memorabilia, photos and collectibles.

Thanks for your interest! You'll be hearing from us.

Get auction updates for similar items

 

Join our mailing list to receive periodic email alerts on our upcoming online auctions which feature collectible militaria items.

Thanks for your interest! You'll be hearing from us.

Get auction updates for similar items

 

Join our mailing list to receive periodic email alerts on our upcoming online auctions which feature fine antique books, rare volumes, and manuscripts.

Thanks for your interest! You'll be hearing from us.

Get auction updates for similar items

 

Join our mailing list to receive periodic email alerts on our upcoming online auctions which feature vintage postcards, RPPCs and collections.

Thanks for your interest! You'll be hearing from us.

Get auction updates for similar items

 

Join our mailing list to receive periodic email alerts on our upcoming online auctions which feature antique photography, albums and important images.

Thanks for your interest! You'll be hearing from us.

Get auction updates for similar items

 

Join our mailing list to receive periodic email alerts on our upcoming online auctions which feature first edition books and collections of firsts.

Thanks for your interest! You'll be hearing from us.

Get auction updates for similar items

 

Join our mailing list to receive periodic email alerts on our upcoming online auctions which feature antique and vintage collectibles related to ocean liners and famous ships.

Thanks for your interest! You'll be hearing from us.

Get auction updates for similar items

 

Join our mailing list to receive periodic email alerts on our upcoming online auctions which feature magic and gambling related books, props, advertising and ephemera.

Thanks for your interest! You'll be hearing from us.

Britannic Auctions

Be the First to Know with Auction Alerts!

Join now for exclusive alerts on must-have collectibles. Don't miss your chance to be ahead of the pack!

Thanks! You'll be hearing from us soon.

Britannic Auctions

Be the First to Know with Auction Alerts!

Join now for exclusive alerts on must-have collectibles. Don't miss your chance to be ahead of the pack!

Thanks! You'll be hearing from us soon.