The Collector’s Guide: How to Identify and Value First Edition Books

November 11, 2023

Cracking the code on how to tell a first edition is key when investigating the value of antique or collectible books, whether they’re old classics or more modern reads.

It might sound tricky, but there’s no one-size-fits-all trick to instantly ID your book’s edition. Fear not, though – plenty of hints can steer you in the right direction. We’re here to help you uncover the unique characteristics that distinguish genuine first edition books.

An Introduction to First Editions

“First edition” means the very first publication of a book.

Collecting first editions has been around for centuries, but it really took off as a formalized hobby in the 19th century.

During this time, people started appreciating the rarity and historical significance of these early prints, turning book collecting into a more organized pursuit.

Fast forward to today, and the passion for collecting first editions is still going strong. Enthusiasts recognize the cultural and monetary value of these gems, making it a lively part of the literary and collector scene.

Why Are First Edition Books Valuable?

A first edition is considered more valuable due to its significance as being the very first appearance of that particular work.

Publishers often follow up with later editions to satisfy demand or correct errors, which can make first editions (relatively) scarce and highly prized, depending on the book.

The appeal of first editions lies in their scarcity. Initial printings often have smaller quantities than later ones, making them a bit like hidden gems for serious collectors. The hunt for these first editions enhances their allure, turning them into sought-after pieces for bibliophiles.

How to Tell if a Book is a First Edition

There are a few key indicators that can guide you in understanding how to tell a first edition.

In modern times, with complicated number lines and publisher’s jargon on a copyright page, there’s lots of data to comb through, but the older a book is, the more challenging it can be to determine what edition it is without expertise. Let’s start with the older books.

Identifying Antique First Edition Books

Antique books (meaning pre-19th century books) don’t have a print run listed. This makes it very tricky to ascertain an antique book’s edition.

Around the 19th century, publishers slowly started identifying editions although not in any consistently helpful way.

Navigating the identification of first editions in antique books from the 16th to the 18th century becomes notably challenging. This task is often most effectively undertaken by a book expert.

Consult a Bibliography for Further Information

When dealing with a specific book, learning how to tell a first edition may require consulting bibliographies – lists that can themselves be considered rare books.

Exploring online archives can be a valuable resource, as numerous institutions have digitized their databases. It’s worth noting that many of these databases operate on a subscription-based model, requiring payment for access.

This is still not a foolproof way of ensuring an antique book is truly a first edition, as the further back you go, the sketchier things become, usually with less information available in the public domain.

Obviously, some authors’ bibliographies have been more documented than others; for instance, Charles Dickens’ most famous bibliographer, John Eckels, dedicated a whole book to Charles Dickens’ First Editions.

First editions, particularly the first state of Dickens in the original publishers’ cloth, can fetch well over five figures at auction.

Being able to ascertain if a book is a first state, essentially a first printing of the first edition, can be identified by a few factors. These can be things like specific errors in the text, pagination, the presence (or absence) of publishers’ advertisements, identifying a specific type of binder’s decoration or simply the color of the cloth used when bound.

Identifying Modern First Editions

Now that we’ve made it past antique first editions, let’s shift our focus to modern literature.

In this section, we’ll explore how to tell a first edition in 20th and 21st century books, unraveling the distinctive features that set them apart. From copyright dates to special call-outs, let’s look at the nuances of edition identification in modern books.

Look for the Copyright Date

When examining a book for first edition indicators, your first go-to clue is the publication date.

If the date printed on the book matches the year of its initial publication, it strongly suggests the possibility of a first edition. To accurately identify whether a book is indeed a first edition, it’s essential to look into the publication history of the title.

Need help decoding a date in Roman Numerals? Use our free Roman numeral converter tool!

Do some research to ascertain the precise date of the book’s first issuance – this will allow you to make a detailed comparison with the printed dates in the book itself. This approach is the first key aspect of understanding how to tell a first edition.

If There’s No Printing Year, Does That Mean It’s a First Edition?

A common misconception, even among many experienced book dealers, is the belief that a book without a printing year is automatically a first edition.

There are always exceptions to the rule, but in lots of cases a book without a printing year shows it to in fact be a later edition.

Later printings can drastically decrease the value of first edition books.

For example: Let’s look at the first edition of “Harry Potter”.

The first run – meaning the first printing – of “Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone” (1997) only had a printing run of 500 books. A total of 250 of those books were immediately distributed to libraries. As we all know, J.K. Rowling’s series became an instant classic and is one of the most collectible of modern first edition books.

Since all the little wizards were enthralled with Harry Potter, Bloomsbury’s went to press again. Their next printing run of “The Philosopher’s Stone” was substantially increased in quantity, running into the thousands. Therefore, the later the print run on “The Philosopher’s Stone”, the less desirable to collectors today.

Spotting “First Edition” on the Copyright Page

If the words “first edition” appear on the copyright page, your book is considered by its publisher to be a first edition.

Many (but not all) publishers use the words “first edition” to identify the initial publication of a book.

Keep in mind though, that some books are issued in both hardback and paperback editions, and each could be labeled as a “first edition” on the copyright page, but only the one truly printed first would be considered a “true first”.

Are signed copies always first editions? Not necessarily. But more often than not, authors will sign a first edition. These might be given out as early gifts in the form of presentational copies or at book signing events. Authors may sign later editions or reprints. Always cross-reference signatures with other first edition indicators.

Check the Number Line or Printing Run

Ok, now we’re getting into some technical stuff – stay with us. Let’s look at the printing run (often referred to as the number line.)

The number line refers to the line of numbers printed on the copyright page.

These numbers are actually identifying the printing run of this book. A printing run, also known as a print run or printings, refers to the total number of copies of a book printed in a single production batch or printing session.

The “number line” became popular in publishing following World War II. We’re grateful for that because it makes identifying the edition of modern 20th century books much simpler.

Grab any book on your shelf and flip to the copyright page (it’s one of the very first pages in the book) to get a look at a typical number line or print run.

How to determine if a book is first edition
A typical number line, plus the printed words “First Edition”. The numbers relate to the printing run also known as “impressions”. Note the numbers in the run include all numbers from 1 to 10. The number “1” indicates that this is a First Edition and a First Printing.

What the Number Line Means

These lines of numbers usually follow a format such as (1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10) where the “1” signifies that the book is a first edition.

Here’s a very basic look at some common number lines you might find in a modern book:

Number LineWhat it Means
1 2 3 4 5 6This indicates a first printing or edition.
2 3 4 5 6Typically signifies a second printing.
6 7 8 9 10Often denotes a later printing.
89 90 91 92Indicates a much later printing in this case.

Different publishers will arrange their number lines differently, so irritatingly, there is no universal system for this. Some international publishers will even mix in letters.

Look for Any Special Call-Outs

Special call-outs on a modern book might be stickers, or blurbs on dust jackets that mention things like “Best Selling” or “Award Winning” or “Book Club Edition”.

These sorts of call-outs indicate that the book has been out long enough to have won awards or gained notoriety. Publishers then re-issued the book in a later edition highlighting these accolades to sell more copies. If you see something like this, it’s almost certain that the book is not a first edition.

International Printings and True First Editions

A true first edition refers to the initial printing of a book and marks the very first time a book is published and made available to the public.

In some cases, a book may be printed in one country first and then in another country later on. The printing that came first would be considered the “true first edition” and tends to hold more value as it was the very first publishing of the book – ever.

Example: “Harry Potter and the Philospher’s Stone”, 1997
“Harry Potter” was first published in the United Kingdom, and only later printed in the United States. The truly valuable copies of “Harry Potter and The Philosopher’s Stone” are the first editions printed in the UK.

The Difference Between a First Edition and a First Printing

They can sound pretty similar, but there’s a world of difference in value.

When a book is sold for the first time, that’s called the “first edition.” It’s the initial printing of a book (after the book proof or advance copy). Technically the phrase “First Edition” consists of the first printing plus any additional printings of the same first edition.

First editions will generally hold the most value if they are both first editions AND first printings.

When there is enough new information or edits to warrant updating the book, a revised second edition may be published. This is often the case with non-fiction books such as text-books.

To a book collector, the phrase “First Edition” refers to a book that was released during the first printing of the “First Edition” (they call this book a “First/First or 1st/1st”).

A 1st/1st is what serious collectors are looking for. A popular book may have had dozens of additional printings causing its first printing to be the most valuable.

The printed words “First Printing” were (very helpfully!) added by the publisher here, which helps to show this is a First Edition, First Printing.

The Role of Dust Jackets in Book Valuation

Let’s not forget the dust jacket! Dust jackets, also known as dust wrappers or book jackets, were not originally a part of book design.

In the early 19th century, books were usually sold with plain bindings. It wasn’t until the late 19th century that publishers began using dust jackets primarily as a protective layer to shield books from dust and wear during transit.

However, the function of dust jackets evolved beyond mere protection.

Publishers recognized an opportunity to use these covers for promotional purposes. By the early 20th century, dust jackets started featuring eye-catching designs, illustrations, and blurbs, transforming them into marketing tools to entice potential readers.

As it relates to our challenge of identifying a first edition book, a dust jacket can be incredibly important in spotting (and valuing) modern first editions. If the book was originally issued with a dust jacket, that is.

You might ask, “Do all first editions have a dust jacket?” No, but many do. While a dust jacket can be a helpful clue in identifying a modern first edition, some first editions may have been released without one.

Clues to a First Edition Hidden on the Dust Jacket

Aside from its own intrinsic value, a well-preserved dust jacket can be a valuable clue in identifying a first edition.

First edition books often have specific characteristics on the dust jacket, such as unclipped corners where the publisher’s price was printed, accurate blurbs, and author bios matching the book’s era.

Doing a little research on some of the information printed on a book’s dust jacket can often yield valuable insights into its edition.

First State Dust Jackets (Yes, They Have “States”, Too)

Then, there’s the desirability of a “first state dust jacket”. Similar to the printing of the book itself, dust jackets will commonly go through different “states”.

In the early stages of publication, books may contain printing imperfections and spelling errors that have slipped by before being noticed and corrected prior to printing – this is true both of the book AND the dust jacket.

Prices, blurbs and information on a dust jacket can be very helpful in identifying an early printing, and in some cases, a first state dust jacket is what can reveal the answer.

Prices as Indicators of Edition

The price listed on a dust jacket can be a revealing clue about how to tell a first edition.

In early printings, publishers might experiment with pricing, and variations can indicate different states or printings.

A subtle change in the listed price could signify a subsequent printing, making it a valuable detail for collectors looking to understand how to tell a first edition.

Example: “To Kill a Mockingbird” by Harper Lee
Consider Harper Lee’s “To Kill a Mockingbird,” initially published in 1960. The first edition dust jacket shows an original price of $3.95. Subsequent printings  have alterations in the price, indicating a different state of the dust jacket.

Blurbs and Descriptions

Blurbs and descriptive text on dust jackets provide additional clues.

A blurb is a brief yet compelling snippet found on the book’s back cover or jacket, offering insights into how to tell a first edition. It’s a short and snappy bit of text that gives you a taste of what the book is about.

Changes in the wording or placement of blurbs can be indicative of different printings, providing valuable markers for edition identification when learning how to tell a first edition. Publishers may tweak promotional content in later printings, making these textual elements crucial in understanding how to tell a first edition.

Example: Agatha Christie’s “Murder on the Orient Express”
In Agatha Christie’s “Murder on the Orient Express,” the first state dust jacket featured a blurb praising her previous book, “The Murder of Roger Ackroyd.” Subsequent states omitted this blurb, offering a subtle distinction for collectors in identifying different printings.

Watch Out for Facsimile Dust Jackets

Some first editions that are incredibly valuable and sought after are most highly prized when they retain their original, first state dust jacket, and in fine condition.

Sometimes, extremely popular books whose dust jackets are notoriously absent, fragile or damaged will be paired with a facsimile (copy) of an original dust jacket.

This is usually done for sake of appearances – a book looks beautiful when neatly dressed in its original jacket, and this makes a lovely presentation. You can even buy facsimile dust jackets to cover your first editions.

If you have an extraordinarily desirable book that was issued with a dust jacket, it’s imperative that the dust jacket be closely examined to determine whether it is authentic or not.

Reputable book dealers and auction houses will always clearly make note when a first edition is placed into a facsimile dust jacket. A facsimile dust jacket adds no value to the book than for looks.

The $33k difference between a real and facsimile dust jacket
As an example, we can take a quick look at Dashiell Hammett’s classic detective novel “The Maltese Falcon” (1930). A fine first edition copy of the book, presented in its original pictorial dust jacket sold at Christie’s in 2023 for a whopping $35,234, whereas fine first edition copies of “Falcon” paired with facsimile dust jackets bring just a fraction of that price, usually around the $1,500 mark.

Further Research and Resources

Determining whether a book is a first edition can be problematic and confusing for amateur book sleuths. To conclusively determine whether your book is a first edition, it’s wise to get in touch with an expert who will be able to put together the various pieces of information unique to the individual book and come up with an answer.

For a deeper understanding of the subject and to master the skill of identifying first editions, these resources are highly recommended:

EXPLORE & LEARN

Learning Guides

In-depth guides on the world of collecting and valuing books, postcards, photography and more.

Have an antique in your attic and wonder what it's worth?

Get Alerts for the Dickensiana Auction

 

Join our mailing list for email alerts on the 2023 Charles Dickens auction.

Thanks for your interest! You'll be hearing from us.

Get auction updates for whatever you collect!

 

Join our mailing list to receive periodic email alerts on our upcoming online auctions.

Let us know your area of collecting or interest and we'll send you updates on that particular subject.

INTERESTS

Thanks for your interest! You'll be hearing from us.

Get auction updates for similar items

 

Join our mailing list to receive periodic email alerts on our upcoming online auctions.

Let us know your area of collecting or interest and we'll send you updates on that particular subject.

Thanks for your interest! You'll be hearing from us.

Get auction updates for similar items

 

Join our mailing list to receive periodic email alerts on our upcoming online auctions which feature vintage Hollywood memorabilia, photos and collectibles.

Thanks for your interest! You'll be hearing from us.

Get auction updates for similar items

 

Join our mailing list to receive periodic email alerts on our upcoming online auctions which feature collectible militaria items.

Thanks for your interest! You'll be hearing from us.

Get auction updates for similar items

 

Join our mailing list to receive periodic email alerts on our upcoming online auctions which feature fine antique books, rare volumes, and manuscripts.

Thanks for your interest! You'll be hearing from us.

Get auction updates for similar items

 

Join our mailing list to receive periodic email alerts on our upcoming online auctions which feature vintage postcards, RPPCs and collections.

Thanks for your interest! You'll be hearing from us.

Get auction updates for similar items

 

Join our mailing list to receive periodic email alerts on our upcoming online auctions which feature antique photography, albums and important images.

Thanks for your interest! You'll be hearing from us.

Get auction updates for similar items

 

Join our mailing list to receive periodic email alerts on our upcoming online auctions which feature first edition books and collections of firsts.

Thanks for your interest! You'll be hearing from us.

Get auction updates for similar items

 

Join our mailing list to receive periodic email alerts on our upcoming online auctions which feature antique and vintage collectibles related to ocean liners and famous ships.

Thanks for your interest! You'll be hearing from us.

Get auction updates for similar items

 

Join our mailing list to receive periodic email alerts on our upcoming online auctions which feature magic and gambling related books, props, advertising and ephemera.

Thanks for your interest! You'll be hearing from us.

Britannic Auctions

Be the First to Know with Auction Alerts!

Join now for exclusive alerts on must-have collectibles. Don't miss your chance to be ahead of the pack!

Thanks! You'll be hearing from us soon.

Britannic Auctions

Be the First to Know with Auction Alerts!

Join now for exclusive alerts on must-have collectibles. Don't miss your chance to be ahead of the pack!

Thanks! You'll be hearing from us soon.